Repeater on the cheap

The wireless signal in our house has difficulty reaching a few spots. On top of that, the PowerBook's metal shell interferes with the (already weak) signal, and makes it impossible to connect.

One solution is to use a repeater to boost the signal. LinkSys already makes a Range Expander, which seems to do the right thing, but at $80, it costs more than the router itself!

DD-WRT, which I already use for QoS, can also turn a $50 router into a repeater (and more!)

The generic name for this is Linking Routers. At a high-level, there are 4 ways to link two (or more) routers together:

• Client -- Router 1 is on the WAN, Router 2 extends the range of Router 1. The catch is that all clients can only connect to Router 2 via a wired connection. Additionally, Router 1 and Router 2 sit on different networks, so it is not possible to do things like "broadcast" between them.
• Client Bridged -- same as Client, but the two routers sit on the same network.
• Repeater -- same as Client, but the clients can connect to Router 2 via wired and wireless. The two routers sit on different networks.
• Repeater Bridged -- same as Repeater, but the two routers sit on the same network.

The easiest and most convenient configuration is the Repeater. Basically, Router 2 acts as just another computer that connects to Router 1, but creates a separate network (with a separate SSID) in its area of influence.

One drawback (to all these configurations) is that the wireless bandwidth is cut in half, roughly, because of collissions within the wireless broadcast between the two routers. This is apparently unavoidable. In our case, the 802.11g protocol is already fast enough for what we use it, that this does not create noticeable slowdowns (and SpeedTest confirms it).

The Client functionality has existed for a while (it even exists in my ancient v23 on my original router), but the Repeater functionality is new, only in v24, and (confusingly) only works right in some versions but not others. Read the documentation very carefully!

While I was researching repeaters, I also briefly looked into whether an 802.11n router might help -- they are supposed to be "faster" and have increased range. Unfortunately, the Linksys own N-products get mixed to bad reviews -- the range is not much increased, neither is the speed, and the installation process leaves much to be desired. Add to that the fact that, to use it, I'd have to get compatible 802.11n PCMCIA cards, and I'm not all that interested or excited about this.

DD-WRT continues to be an exceptional product, especially when combined with a solid piece of hardware like the WRT54GL.